Gainium vs 3Commas
Gainium and 3Commas both help crypto traders automate their strategies — but they represent fundamentally different approaches to the problem. 3Commas is one of the oldest cloud-based bot platforms (founded 2017) with millions of registered users, a mature feature set, and broad exchange support. Gainium (founded 2021) is an open-source, education-first platform that believes understanding should come before automation. This comparison breaks down where each excels.
Gainium
Open source, no-code crypto trading platform
3Commas
Crypto Trading Bots & Automation Platform
Gainium for traders who want open-source transparency, education tools, and unlimited self-hosting. 3Commas for traders who want a mature cloud platform with broad exchange support and asset management features.
Gainium is best for
- Traders who want open-source, self-hosted bots for free
- Education-first approach (manual backtester, journal, rulebooks)
- Combo bots (unique Grid + DCA hybrid)
- Unlimited backtesting without subscription limits
- Workflow automation via native n8n integration
3Commas is best for
- Traders who want a mature, cloud-only platform
- Signal bots with TradingView Pine Script integration
- Asset managers managing multiple client accounts
- Broad exchange support (16 exchanges)
- Mobile app users (iOS and Android)
Feature Comparison
A detailed look at how each platform handles the features that matter most.
Visual drag-and-drop strategy builder. No programming needed.
No coding for basic bots. Pine Script knowledge optional for Signal bot custom strategies.
Coding Required
Visual drag-and-drop strategy builder. No programming needed.
No coding for basic bots. Pine Script knowledge optional for Signal bot custom strategies.
Sign up, connect exchange, pick a template or configure a bot.
Sign up, connect exchange via Fast Connect or API keys, configure a bot.
Time to First Bot
Sign up, connect exchange, pick a template or configure a bot.
Sign up, connect exchange via Fast Connect or API keys, configure a bot.
Use the cloud platform instantly, or self-host the Community Edition via Docker for free.
No self-hosted option. All bots run on 3Commas servers.
Deployment
Use the cloud platform instantly, or self-host the Community Edition via Docker for free.
No self-hosted option. All bots run on 3Commas servers.
Designed for all skill levels. Visual interface with built-in education tools.
Straightforward bot setup, but advanced features (Signal bots, Pine Script) require learning.
Learning Curve
Designed for all skill levels. Visual interface with built-in education tools.
Straightforward bot setup, but advanced features (Signal bots, Pine Script) require learning.
Customizable triggers via indicators, webhooks, or conditions.
DCA bots with single-pair and multi-pair modes. Configurable safety orders and take profit.
DCA Bots
Customizable triggers via indicators, webhooks, or conditions.
DCA bots with single-pair and multi-pair modes. Configurable safety orders and take profit.
Configure visually with range, grid levels, and order sizes.
Grid bots for spot trading. Configurable price range and grid levels.
Grid Bots
Configure visually with range, grid levels, and order sizes.
Grid bots for spot trading. Configurable price range and grid levels.
Trigger bots from external signals via webhooks.
Purpose-built Signal bot with TradingView integration and 100+ deal start signals.
Signal Bots
Trigger bots from external signals via webhooks.
Purpose-built Signal bot with TradingView integration and 100+ deal start signals.
Flagship hybrid combining Grid + DCA mechanics. No other platform offers this.
No hybrid bot type. DCA and Grid are separate.
Combo Bots
Flagship hybrid combining Grid + DCA mechanics. No other platform offers this.
No hybrid bot type. DCA and Grid are separate.
Hedge bot for managing risk with simultaneous long and short positions.
No dedicated hedge bot type.
Hedge Bots
Hedge bot for managing risk with simultaneous long and short positions.
No dedicated hedge bot type.
Smart trading terminal with enhanced features.
SmartTrade with concurrent TP/SL, trailing, and multi-target selling.
SmartTrade Terminal
Smart trading terminal with enhanced features.
SmartTrade with concurrent TP/SL, trailing, and multi-target selling.
Binance, Bybit, Bitget, KuCoin, Coinbase, OKX, Kraken, Hyperliquid.
Binance, Bybit, OKX, KuCoin, Kraken, Coinbase, Gate, Bitget, HTX, Gemini, Bitstamp, Bitfinex, and more.
Supported Exchanges
Binance, Bybit, Bitget, KuCoin, Coinbase, OKX, Kraken, Hyperliquid.
Binance, Bybit, OKX, KuCoin, Kraken, Coinbase, Gate, Bitget, HTX, Gemini, Bitstamp, Bitfinex, and more.
Futures trading included on all plans at no extra cost.
Futures restricted to Pro ($50/mo) and Expert ($140/mo). Starter plan is spot-only.
Futures Trading
Futures trading included on all plans at no extra cost.
Futures restricted to Pro ($50/mo) and Expert ($140/mo). Starter plan is spot-only.
Unlimited free trading on Hyperliquid DEX.
CEX only. No decentralized exchange support.
DEX Support
Unlimited free trading on Hyperliquid DEX.
CEX only. No decentralized exchange support.
Open-source indicators library with 45+ indicators. Visual configuration, no external tools needed.
Only 11 built-in indicators (RSI, MACD, Bollinger Bands, MA, ADX, Stochastic, Parabolic SAR, MFI, CCI, UO, Heikin Ashi). More available via TradingView integration but requires external setup.
Technical Indicators
Open-source indicators library with 45+ indicators. Visual configuration, no external tools needed.
Only 11 built-in indicators (RSI, MACD, Bollinger Bands, MA, ADX, Stochastic, Parabolic SAR, MFI, CCI, UO, Heikin Ashi). More available via TradingView integration but requires external setup.
No copy trading or signal marketplace.
Signal marketplace with third-party trading strategies and bot presets.
Copy Trading
No copy trading or signal marketplace.
Signal marketplace with third-party trading strategies and bot presets.
Runs on your machine. Truly unlimited — free even without a subscription.
100–5,000 backtests/month depending on plan. DCA: 1–full history. Grid: 4 months max.
Automated Backtesting
Runs on your machine. Truly unlimited — free even without a subscription.
100–5,000 backtests/month depending on plan. DCA: 1–full history. Grid: 4 months max.
Unlimited on Community Edition. Cloud version uses plan credits.
Paper trading mode available for testing strategies with simulated funds.
Paper Trading
Unlimited on Community Edition. Cloud version uses plan credits.
Paper trading mode available for testing strategies with simulated funds.
Replay the market bar by bar. Blind mode hides dates and prices so you trade purely on what you see.
No manual replay tool.
Manual Backtester
Replay the market bar by bar. Blind mode hides dates and prices so you trade purely on what you see.
No manual replay tool.
Auto-logged entries for every manual backtest. Tag decisions, filter by conditions, review patterns.
No built-in journaling.
Trading Journal
Auto-logged entries for every manual backtest. Tag decisions, filter by conditions, review patterns.
No built-in journaling.
Your trading operating manual — written rules that prevent emotional overrides.
No structured decision framework.
Rulebooks
Your trading operating manual — written rules that prevent emotional overrides.
No structured decision framework.
Learn by doing — manual backtests, journals, and rulebooks are core features.
Blog, YouTube, help center. No built-in education tools.
Learning Approach
Learn by doing — manual backtests, journals, and rulebooks are core features.
Blog, YouTube, help center. No built-in education tools.
Built-in AI for market analysis and strategy suggestions. No usage caps.
New AI Assistant feature. Limited to 1M tokens/month across all plans.
AI Assistant
Built-in AI for market analysis and strategy suggestions. No usage caps.
New AI Assistant feature. Limited to 1M tokens/month across all plans.
Interact with your account via Telegram. Proactive heartbeat alerts and scheduled tasks.
No conversational AI agent. Telegram used for notifications only.
AI Agents
Interact with your account via Telegram. Proactive heartbeat alerts and scheduled tasks.
No conversational AI agent. Telegram used for notifications only.
Dedicated n8n-nodes-gainium package. Build multi-step workflows without code.
No workflow engine. Limited to bot logic and TradingView signals.
Workflow Automation
Dedicated n8n-nodes-gainium package. Build multi-step workflows without code.
No workflow engine. Limited to bot logic and TradingView signals.
Receive TradingView alerts to trigger bot actions via webhooks.
TradingView alerts via webhooks and Pine Script execution for Signal bots.
TradingView Integration
Receive TradingView alerts to trigger bot actions via webhooks.
TradingView alerts via webhooks and Pine Script execution for Signal bots.
Incoming webhooks to trigger bots from external signals. Outgoing webhooks to notify external systems of bot events.
Incoming TradingView webhooks for Signal bots and SmartTrade. No outgoing webhook support.
Webhook Support
Incoming webhooks to trigger bots from external signals. Outgoing webhooks to notify external systems of bot events.
Incoming TradingView webhooks for Signal bots and SmartTrade. No outgoing webhook support.
Responsive web app. No native mobile app.
Full-featured mobile apps with almost all desktop features.
Mobile App
Responsive web app. No native mobile app.
Full-featured mobile apps with almost all desktop features.
Deal alerts, bot notifications, and full conversational AI agent interaction via Telegram.
Deal notifications and alerts via Telegram.
Telegram Integration
Deal alerts, bot notifications, and full conversational AI agent interaction via Telegram.
Deal notifications and alerts via Telegram.
Complete API access for programmatic control.
Starter/Pro: read-only. Expert: read & write. Developer-friendly REST API.
API Access
Complete API access for programmatic control.
Starter/Pro: read-only. Expert: read & write. Developer-friendly REST API.
Full platform code on GitHub. Community Edition free and unlimited.
Proprietary SaaS platform. No source code available.
Open Source
Full platform code on GitHub. Community Edition free and unlimited.
Proprietary SaaS platform. No source code available.
Run unlimited bots on your own server. Free forever.
Cloud-only. Must use 3Commas servers.
Self-Hosted Option
Run unlimited bots on your own server. Free forever.
Cloud-only. Must use 3Commas servers.
Your data lives on your device. Works offline.
All data on 3Commas servers. Dependent on service availability.
Data Ownership
Your data lives on your device. Works offline.
All data on 3Commas servers. Dependent on service availability.
No known security breaches.
December 2022: API keys leaked, resulting in unauthorized trades. Initially denied, later confirmed the breach.
Security Track Record
No known security breaches.
December 2022: API keys leaked, resulting in unauthorized trades. Initially denied, later confirmed the breach.
250 Bot Credits on cloud. Backtesting always free and unlimited.
Free trial with full access. Starter plan is the entry paid tier.
Free Tier
250 Bot Credits on cloud. Backtesting always free and unlimited.
Free trial with full access. Starter plan is the entry paid tier.
Unlimited bots, all exchanges, multi-pair. Free forever.
No self-hosted option. Must subscribe to paid plans.
Self-hosted Cost
Unlimited bots, all exchanges, multi-pair. Free forever.
No self-hosted option. Must subscribe to paid plans.
Subscription plans for cloud hosting with additional features.
Starter: spot only, 5 DCA bots. Pro: futures, 20 DCA bots. Expert: 1K bots, full API. Asset Manager from $223/mo.
Paid Plans
Subscription plans for cloud hosting with additional features.
Starter: spot only, 5 DCA bots. Pro: futures, 20 DCA bots. Expert: 1K bots, full API. Asset Manager from $223/mo.
No bot limits on Community Edition. Cloud plans have credit-based limits.
Starter: 5 DCA + 2 Grid. Pro: 20 DCA + 10 Grid. Expert: 1K each.
Bot Limits
No bot limits on Community Edition. Cloud plans have credit-based limits.
Starter: 5 DCA + 2 Grid. Pro: 20 DCA + 10 Grid. Expert: 1K each.
Connect unlimited exchange accounts on all plans.
1 active API key (Starter), 3 (Pro), 15 (Expert). Additional connections limited to portfolio tracking.
Multi-Account Management
Connect unlimited exchange accounts on all plans.
1 active API key (Starter), 3 (Pro), 15 (Expert). Additional connections limited to portfolio tracking.
No dedicated asset management features.
White-label portal, bulk deployments, automated performance reports. From $223/mo.
Asset Manager Solution
No dedicated asset management features.
White-label portal, bulk deployments, automated performance reports. From $223/mo.
Track portfolio across connected exchanges.
Create and balance portfolios. Copy and edit coin ratios.
Portfolio Management
Track portfolio across connected exchanges.
Create and balance portfolios. Copy and edit coin ratios.
Help center, blog with guides and comparison articles.
Comprehensive help center, blog, YouTube tutorials.
Documentation
Help center, blog with guides and comparison articles.
Comprehensive help center, blog, YouTube tutorials.
Community forum at community.gainium.io plus active Telegram group.
Large Telegram community. Active social media presence.
Community
Community forum at community.gainium.io plus active Telegram group.
Large Telegram community. Active social media presence.
Fast response times via Telegram, community forum, and email. Direct access to the team.
AI-first live chat with slow escalation to human agents. Priority support reserved for Expert plan.
Customer Support
Fast response times via Telegram, community forum, and email. Direct access to the team.
AI-first live chat with slow escalation to human agents. Priority support reserved for Expert plan.
4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot. See reviews at https://www.trustpilot.com/review/gainium.io
4.3 out of 5 on Trustpilot with 1,754+ reviews.
Trustpilot Rating
4.4 out of 5 on Trustpilot. See reviews at https://www.trustpilot.com/review/gainium.io
4.3 out of 5 on Trustpilot with 1,754+ reviews.
About Gainium
Gainium's biggest differentiator is its open-source Community Edition — you can self-host unlimited bots on your own server for free, forever. No bot limits, no subscription required. Beyond self-hosting, Gainium is built around education: the manual backtester replays markets bar by bar (with blind mode to remove bias), the trading journal auto-logs your decisions, and rulebooks keep you disciplined. The unique Combo Bot combines Grid and DCA mechanics — no other platform offers this hybrid strategy. Backtesting is unlimited and truly free, running locally on your machine with no monthly caps. AI Agents on Telegram give you a conversational trading assistant with proactive alerts, and native n8n integration enables workflow automation without code.
About 3Commas
3Commas has spent nearly a decade building a comprehensive cloud trading platform. With 16 supported exchanges (including Binance, Bybit, OKX, Kraken, Coinbase, and Gate), it covers more venues than most competitors. The Signal bot with deep TradingView integration and Pine Script execution is a standout — you can pipe any TradingView alert directly into automated trades. The SmartTrade terminal offers concurrent TP/SL, trailing features, and multi-target selling. For professionals, the Asset Manager product provides white-label portals, bulk bot deployment, and automated performance reporting from $223/month. Full-featured mobile apps on iOS and Android round out the experience. The new QuantPilot AI platform (in early access) signals 3Commas is investing heavily in autonomous trading agents.
The Bottom Line
The choice comes down to philosophy and priorities. If you want a mature cloud platform with broad exchange support, Signal bots, TradingView integration, mobile apps, and professional asset management — 3Commas delivers. If you want open-source transparency, self-hosted freedom, built-in education tools, unlimited backtesting, and the unique Combo bot — Gainium is the better fit. 3Commas has the track record and feature breadth; Gainium has the openness, education focus, and zero-cost self-hosting that 3Commas fundamentally cannot offer.
3Commas vs Gainium FAQ
Ready to try Gainium?
See for yourself how Gainium compares to 3Commas. Start with the free tier — no credit card required.